I would say that it has been a failure.
I often used to use it when there was congestion around the north of Birmingham due to roadworks, but since the roadworks are now clear traffic flows freely. I will also add, I would only ever use to toll if the company were paying!
Looking at the company finances, it would also appear to be a bit of a failure...

However, as they are part of a (much) larger group things might not be as first appears...
